Medicine Makers: Heroes, Villains, or Something In Between?

• It's About Money AND Health: Drug companies need to make money to stay in business, but they also save lives. This creates complicated situations where people wonder if profits come before patients.

---

• Past Mistakes Still Sting: Some companies have done bad things before, like hiding dangerous side effects or charging too much for life-saving drugs. People remember this stuff.

---

• Science Takes Time: Good medicine requires tons of testing and research, which is expensive and slow. Sometimes people want faster answers than science can safely provide.

---

• Everyone's Experience Is Different: Some people have been helped by medicines, while others have had bad experiences. Personal stories shape how much we trust these companies.

What if you were a scientist who discovered a cure for a rare disease, but it cost $2 million to make each dose?

• Role play: Take turns being the scientist, a patient who needs the medicine, and a company executive. Discuss how much the medicine should cost and why.

What if you were a news reporter investigating whether a company hid information about side effects?

• Role play: One person plays the reporter asking tough questions, while the other plays a company spokesperson trying to explain their actions.

What if you had to decide whether to trust a new vaccine during a pandemic when you only had limited information?

• Role play: Debate the pros and cons of waiting for more data versus acting quickly to protect people, with each person arguing a different perspective.

Are all drug companies bad?

No way! Many drug companies have created life-saving medicines. But like any business, some make better choices than others. The key is learning to evaluate each situation individually.

Why are medicines so expensive?

Creating new medicines costs billions of dollars and takes 10-15 years of research and testing. Companies need to make back that money, but sometimes they charge way more than seems fair.

How do we know if medicines are safe?

Medicines go through lots of testing before they're approved, and agencies like the FDA check the data. But no medicine is 100% safe for everyone, which is why we keep monitoring them.

• During COVID-19, some people praised pharmaceutical companies for developing vaccines quickly, while others worried they were rushed too fast through safety testing. (CDC and FDA vaccine approval timelines)

---

• The EpiPen price controversy, where the cost jumped from $100 to $600, making it hard for people with allergies to afford life-saving medicine. (Congressional hearings on EpiPen pricing 2016)

---

• Insulin pricing debates, where the same medicine that costs $300 in the US costs $40 in other countries, leading to rationing and health problems. (American Diabetes Association pricing studies)

---

• The opioid crisis, where some companies were accused of downplaying addiction risks while promoting pain medications heavily to doctors. (Department of Justice settlements with pharmaceutical companies)

• Trust in drug companies is complicated because they need to make money while helping people stay healthy

---

• Past mistakes and controversies make some people more skeptical of pharmaceutical companies' claims

---

• Good medicine requires expensive research and testing, but sometimes companies charge more than seems fair

---

• The best approach is asking good questions and looking at evidence rather than trusting or distrusting blindly